Chapter 14: Firms in Competitive Markets

How firms decide how much to produce — and why competition drives price to the lowest possible cost

What Is a Competitive Market?

A perfectly competitive market is an idealized baseline for how prices and quantities are set. Most real markets are more complicated, but the model captures powerful truths about industries with many rivals selling similar products.

Four Defining Characteristics

Many buyers & sellers no one can affect the price
Identical products homogeneous goods
Free entry & exit no barriers in the long run
Perfect information buyers know all prices

The key consequence: every firm is a price taker — too small to influence the market price. It simply observes the price and decides how much to produce.

Revenue of a Competitive Firm

Because the firm takes the price as given, selling an extra unit always brings in exactly P in revenue.

Total Revenue TR = P × Q revenue rises linearly with output
Average Revenue AR = TR / Q = P always equals price
Marginal Revenue MR = ΔTR / ΔQ = P each unit adds exactly P to revenue

For a competitive firm, P = AR = MR — unique to competitive markets.

Market sets P*; the firm takes it as given and sells any quantity at that price.

Key insight: The firm's demand curve is horizontal (perfectly elastic) even though market demand slopes down. The firm is too small to affect the price.

Profit Maximization

Profit = TR − TC

The firm finds the profit-maximizing output through marginal analysis — comparing the revenue from one more unit to its cost.

The MR = MC Rule

At any given output level, ask: "If I produce one more unit, does that help or hurt?"

  • If MR > MC: produce more — the extra unit earns more than it costs.
  • If MR < MC: produce less — the extra unit costs more than it earns.
  • If MR = MC: stop — profit is at its maximum.
Profit-maximizing rule Produce Q where P = MC

Profit is maximized where P = MC (green dot). The green-shaded rectangle is economic profit: (P − ATC) × Q*.

Why MR = MC works: Each unit brings in MR but costs MC. Keep expanding while MR > MC. At MR = MC, the last unit earns exactly what it costs — profit can't be improved.

The Firm's Short-Run Supply Decision

What if the price is so low the firm loses money? Should it keep producing or shut down? It depends on whether revenue covers variable costs.

The Shutdown Condition

In the short run, fixed costs are sunk — owed whether the firm produces or not. So the only question: does producing cover variable costs?

Fixed costs are sunk. A restaurant owner with a signed lease should keep operating as long as revenue covers food, labor, and utilities — the lease is owed either way.

Three Short-Run Cases

Case 1: Profit

P > ATC

Price exceeds ATC. The firm earns positive economic profit.

Case 2: Loss

AVC < P < ATC

Price covers VC but not all FC. Firm loses less by staying open.

Case 3: Shutdown

P < AVC

Price doesn't cover VC. Shut down — producing deepens losses.

The gold dot marks the shutdown point (min AVC).

The Short-Run Supply Curve

Combine the two rules: produce where P = MC, unless P < min AVC (then shut down).

Min AVC is the shutdown point. At any lower price, no output level can cover even variable costs — every unit produced deepens the loss beyond the fixed costs already owed.

Drag the price slider to see how the firm responds across all three cases.

$18

Firm Decision

Price (P) $18.00
Optimal Q*

ATC at Q*
AVC at Q*

Profit/Loss

Adjust the slider to see the firm's decision.

Entry, Exit, and Long-Run Equilibrium

In the long run, firms can enter or exit. This drives competitive markets toward their most remarkable result: zero economic profit.

Entry and Exit Decisions

Enter if P > ATC positive economic profit attracts new firms
Exit if P < ATC losses drive existing firms out
Long-run equilibrium P = min ATC zero economic profit — no incentive to enter or exit

The Adjustment Process

P > ATC → positive profit → new firms enter → supply increases → price falls back to min ATC. P < ATC → losses → firms exit → supply decreases → price rises back to min ATC.

Entry shifts market supply right, pushing price from P₁ down to P* = min ATC. The firm earns zero economic profit in the long run — the defining feature of perfect competition.

The Long-Run Equilibrium Condition

The firm operates at min ATC — the only price where neither entry nor exit occurs:

Long-run equilibrium: P = MC = min ATC
"Zero economic profit" doesn't mean owners are poor. It includes a normal return on their time and investment (opportunity cost). Zero profit means the business earns exactly enough to keep the owner in — no surplus beyond opportunity cost.

The Supply Curve in a Competitive Market

Short-Run Market Supply

With a fixed number of firms, the market supply curve is the horizontal sum of all firms' MC curves above AVC — at any price, add up each firm's quantity.

1,000 firms each supplying 10 units at P = $15 → market supply = 10,000 units. Market supply is much flatter (more elastic) than any single firm's curve.

Long-Run Market Supply: Three Industry Types

The long-run supply shape depends on what happens to input prices as the industry grows:

Constant Cost Input prices unchanged as industry grows. LR supply is horizontal at min ATC.
Increasing Cost Competition for scarce inputs bids up prices. New firms face higher costs. LR supply slopes upward.
Decreasing Cost Suppliers benefit from scale — input costs fall. LR supply slopes downward. Rare.

Constant-cost: flat LRS. Increasing-cost: upward LRS. Decreasing-cost: downward LRS.

Why Even LR Upward-Sloping Supply?

If firms earn zero profit, why isn't LR supply always flat? Because of input markets. In oil, the best drilling sites get used first — later entrants face higher costs. The equilibrium price rises not because firms earn excess profit, but because every firm's min ATC is higher.

LR supply is more elastic than SR supply. In the short run, only existing firms adjust output. In the long run, entry and exit also respond — making markets more responsive to price changes over time.

The Big Ideas in Chapter 14

  • Competitive market: many buyers/sellers, identical products, free entry/exit, perfect information. Every firm is a price taker: P = AR = MR.
  • Profit-maximizing rule: produce where P = MC. If P > MC, produce more; if P < MC, produce less.
  • Fixed costs are sunk in the SR. Shut down only if P < AVC — otherwise stay open even at a loss.
  • SR supply curve = MC curve above min AVC. Below min AVC, supply = 0.
  • Positive profit → entry → more supply → price falls. Losses → exit → less supply → price rises. Both push toward LR equilibrium.
  • LR equilibrium: P = MC = min ATC. Zero economic profit — firms earn exactly their opportunity cost.
  • LR supply: horizontal (constant-cost), upward (increasing-cost), or downward (decreasing-cost) depending on input prices.